Fermion ResearchFermion Research

Phonon/facts checked 13 November 2026

Phonon-2.5 vs ElevenLabs Scribe v2

Scribe v2 is the more accurate English transcriber of the two on public test sets. Phonon-2.5 is the one you can download, run offline and pay nothing per hour for.

Phonon-2.5 downloads and benchmarks

The short answer

For the lowest English word error from a hosted API, ElevenLabs Scribe v2 is ahead: 4.06 % on the Open ASR Leaderboard's seven English sets, against 5.06 % for Phonon-2.5 and 4.82 % for Phonon-2.5 English, and lower on every one of the seven sets. Choose Phonon-2.5 when audio cannot go to a third-party cloud, when it must work offline or on a device, or when hourly fees are the problem.

ElevenLabs has since released Scribe v3; the leaderboard snapshot we compare against has the Scribe v2 row.

Side by side

ElevenLabs facts from elevenlabs.io/pricing/api and the ElevenLabs docs, read 2026-11-13.

Phonon-2.5ElevenLabs Scribe v2
Model typeOpen weights on Hugging FaceHosted API
Size156 MB download (Phonon-2.5 English: 158 MB)Not published
Languages25 European languages (Phonon-2.5 English: English only)90+
English word error, seven Open ASR sets5.06 % (Phonon-2.5 English: 4.82 %)4.06 %
Price per audio hourNo per-hour fee when self-hosted$0.20 (Scribe v2); $0.22 (Scribe v2 Realtime)
Where it runsYour hardware: CPUs (Linux x86-64 and arm64, Windows x86-64), Apple silicon, NVIDIA GPUs, AndroidElevenLabs cloud
StreamingYes, live WebSocket from fermion serveScribe v2 Realtime
DiarizationNoYes
Word timestampsYes (--json output)Yes
OtherVerbatim outputAudio event tags (laughter, applause); keyterm prompting; files up to 5 GB

English, set by set

Scribe v2 is lower on all seven sets. The smallest gap is AMI meetings (8.19 % against 8.76 % for Phonon-2.5 English); the largest relative gaps are Earnings-22 and VoxPopuli.

Word error rate in %, lower is better. Phonon rows: our run of the leaderboard's code on the full sets. Rival rows: the Open ASR Leaderboard, snapshot 2026-09-25.
Test setPhonon-2.5Phonon-2.5 EnglishElevenLabs Scribe v2
LibriSpeech clean1.601.641.06
LibriSpeech other3.413.562.33
AMI9.128.768.19
Earnings-226.726.224.80
GigaSpeech8.047.997.63
SPGISpeech3.313.313.01
VoxPopuli3.232.281.41
Average of the seven5.064.824.06

Where ElevenLabs Scribe is the better choice

  • English accuracy: lower word error on every Open ASR set in the snapshot.
  • Breadth: more than 90 languages against Phonon-2.5's 25.
  • Richer output: speaker diarization, audio event tags and keyterm prompting (up to 1,000 terms in batch).
  • Long files: up to 5 GB and 15 hours per request.

Where Phonon-2.5 is the better choice

  • On-device and offline: a 156 MB model that runs on a laptop CPU, a Mac or an Android phone with no network.
  • No hourly fee: at $0.20 per hour, 10,000 hours of Scribe v2 is $2,000 at list price; self-hosted Phonon costs the hardware.
  • Data control: nothing is sent to a third party, which can settle a compliance review before it starts.
  • A pinned model: open weights do not change under you, so results stay reproducible.
pip install fermion-research
fermion transcribe phonon-2.5 interview.wav --json
fermion serve phonon-2.5   # POST /v1/audio/transcriptions, GET /v1/audio/stream

Questions

Is ElevenLabs Scribe more accurate than Phonon-2.5?
Yes in English: Scribe v2 averages 4.06 % word error on the Open ASR Leaderboard's seven sets, lower than Phonon-2.5 (5.06 %) and Phonon-2.5 English (4.82 %) on every set.
How much does ElevenLabs Scribe v2 cost?
ElevenLabs lists Scribe v2 at $0.20 per audio hour and Scribe v2 Realtime at $0.22 per hour, with keyterm prompting extra (API pricing page, read 2026-11-13).
Can Scribe run offline or on my own servers?
ElevenLabs offers Scribe as a hosted API. Phonon-2.5 is open weights and runs offline on CPUs, Apple silicon, NVIDIA GPUs and Android.
Does Phonon-2.5 tag laughter or label speakers like Scribe?
No. Phonon-2.5 returns verbatim text with word timestamps. Scribe v2 adds speaker diarization and audio event tags.
Which languages do both cover?
Scribe v2 supports more than 90 languages, which takes in Phonon-2.5's main European languages. Phonon-2.5 covers 25 European languages in one 156 MB model.

Related

Sources and method

  • Scribe prices: elevenlabs.io/pricing/api, read 2026-11-13.
  • Scribe languages, diarization, timestamps, keyterms, file limits and Scribe v3: elevenlabs.io/docs/capabilities/speech-to-text and elevenlabs.io/docs/overview/models, read 2026-11-13.
  • Rival English word error: Open ASR Leaderboard, seven English sets, snapshot 2026-09-25 (huggingface.co/spaces/hf-audio/open_asr_leaderboard).
  • Phonon-2.5 and Phonon-2.5 English: Fermion Research measurement, Phonon-2.5 release post (2026-10-22), Open ASR Leaderboard scoring code, full test sets of the same seven sets.

Canonical: https://www.fermionresearch.com/models/phonon-2-5/vs-elevenlabs-scribe/